After seven years and four seasons of You, it’s time for the story of deceptively charming serial killer Joe Goldberg to conclude. For the psychological thriller’s fifth and final season, executive producer Sera Gamble (Supernatural), who co-created the series with Greg Berlanti (The Flash), passed showrunning duties to longtime You writers Michael Foley (How to Get Away with Murder) and Justin W. Lo (Grosse Pointe Garden Society).
Season 5 explores You’s core themes — love, obsession, violence, abandonment, privilege, privacy, and toxic relationships — with a deep dive into remorse, regret, and being haunted by past mistakes. While I would’ve loved to see a few more familiar characters and callbacks, these ten episodes had me laughing, gasping, crying, and laughing some more.
Warning: Spoilers for Seasons 1–4
In You’s Season 4 two-parter, Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley) traded in the California suburbs of Madre Linda for the streets of London, England. He becomes a professor of American literature at Darcy College, going by his new identity, Jonathan Moore. He meets another professor, Malcolm (Stephen Hagan), who introduces him to his group of wealthy friends. From the start, Malcolm’s sort of girlfriend Kate Glavin (Charlotte Ritchie) is suspicious of Joe/Jonathan’s arrival. She isn’t like his other love interests (or victims) we’ve seen; she’s cold, blunt, and rightfully wary of his intentions, though he wins her over in the end.

The end of Season 3 showed Joe trying to track down Marienne Bellamy (Tati Gabrielle) in Paris, which led him to a London art fair. She reacts appropriately, running at the sight of him. His way of proving he’s not a bad man is to let her go. We don’t see her again until Part 2, when we learn Joe put her in a new glass cage, all while in a dissociative state. It’s revealed that his antagonistic partner in crime, politician Rhys Montrose (Ed Speleers), was all in his head, and he’s never met the real Rhys.
In a dream sequence, Joe has to face Guinevere Beck (Elizabeth Lail) and Love Quinn (Victoria Pedretti), who force him to confront the truth about himself — that he’s a delusional abuser and killer of women, not their chivalrous white knight. He attempts to kill himself by jumping off a bridge, but ultimately survives, thanks to the thick plot armor. He tells Kate a small fraction of his actual body count, leaving out that he also killed her controlling father, Tom Lockwood (Greg Kinnear). She accepts him, helps him frame his curious student Nadia (Amy-Leigh Hickman), and spins a “second chance at life” story that paints Joe as a victim. We end on an ominous note; even though he and Kate promised to “keep each other good,” Joe now fully accepts himself as a killer.
For a more in-depth recap, check out Penn Badgley’s hilarious video.

Season 5 picks up three years later with Joe and Kate as a power couple. She’s now CEO of the Lockwood Corporation, while he’s sort of just there at her side. The public calls him Prince Charming, a perfect husband who holds his wife’s purse and vaguely helps her with philanthropic efforts. Kate also helped Joe get Henry (Frankie DeMaio), now a 6-year-old precocious book lover, back from his Madre Linda dads, Dante (Ben Mehl) and Lansing (Noel Arthur).
Joe married into a wealthy family before, but the Lockwoods aren’t the same as the Quinns. They’re vicious manipulators with endless money, resources, and influence. Kate’s half-sister Raegan (Anna Camp) resents her for being their father’s favorite and taking over as CEO. Camp gives a fantastic dual performance as the ruthless Raegan and her bubbly twin Maddie, two characters with very different agendas, personalities, and emotions. Kate’s only blood-related confidant is half-brother Teddy Lockwood (Griffin Matthews), who was only welcomed into the family when Kate became CEO. He likes Joe, and Joe (surprisingly) likes him; they both have a rags-to-riches trajectory and still feel like outsiders in this family.

Kate and Joe’s relationship is seemingly stable. He hasn’t killed anyone since they left London, but when an opportunity, or more like a threat, presents itself, he tries to find a work-murder balance. Kate grew up watching her dad “handle” his enemies in violent ways, and now that her husband is starting to do the same, she’s conflicted.
Like most anti-hero stories, we’re rooting against the voice of logic and reason because we want to see the protagonist do awful things. When Kate tries to condemn Joe’s killer tendencies, the knee-jerk reaction is to roll our eyes and scoff at her moral superiority, even though she’s right. She’s like Love in that she calls Joe out on his hypocrisy and isn’t afraid to go head-to-head despite knowing what he’s capable of. She loves deeply and protects her friends and family, even the ones she hates. She doesn’t think of murder as a solution.

Joe keeps himself busy restoring Mooney’s, which he bought with Lockwood money. He hires one employee named Bronte (Madeline Brewer), a young, spirited playwright who broke into the bookstore. She’s an endearing character, described by Joe as “frustrating and utterly captivating all at once.” Bronte regularly speaks in abbreviations and internet slang, which might turn some viewers off. However, she’s self-aware that she’s a mess, and we know Joe can’t resist a literary-loving woman with a complicated life. Brewer has already seen some backlash and expects more, telling Vanity Fair, “People aren’t going to like Bronte for one reason or another. They’ll love to hate her — or hate to love her.”
The return to New York in Season 5 is a nostalgic and fitting setting for Joe’s final chapter. It’s interesting to see him try to be the new him and the old him at the same time. He appreciates his headstrong, kindhearted wife and how she made it possible for him to come home and have his own name again. However, as soon as Kate starts to judge his actions, he goes back to his usual “no one will ever accept the real me” mindset. Delusional as ever, Joe begins to fixate on Bronte, someone he assumes would be more open to dating a man who’d kill for her because she likes dark romance fiction.

Each season, Joe has had to adapt to a new environment, while we adapt to the shifts in tone and cinematography. The jump from Season 1’s warm and dreamy New York to bright, sunny Los Angeles in Season 2 was a bit jarring, but quickly proved to be a fun change of scenery. Season 3 maintained some of the LA brightness in Madre Linda, though muted. I definitely miss the Agatha Christie atmosphere of Season 4’s dark academia London setting. Season 5 sort of blends these different styles with a little of Season 1’s glow, Season 2’s liveliness, Season 3’s colorful claustrophobia, and the darkness of Season 4.
You comes to an end with a dramatic, suspenseful, darkly funny, and emotionally riveting fifth and final season. There’s a lot of pressure to stick the landing, and it’s hard to say how audiences will feel about the overall season, which has quite a few subplots and loose ends. However, the powerful performances, especially from Badgley, elevate the storylines. How much fans enjoy the mostly satisfying finale depends on their idea of justice, whether they actually want Joe to suffer the consequences, and who they want to see bring him down.
You Season 5 premieres April 24, 2025, on Netflix.
The post Review: Joe Goldberg Comes Full Circle in the Riveting Fifth and Final Season of ‘You’ appeared first on Black Girl Nerds.